PRINT THIS WINDOW
CLOSE THIS WINDOW

RETURN TO SAFETY ARTICLES MAIN PAGE

The Rural Missouri NEWS Service
Jim McCarty 573-635-6857, ext. 3402

January 2009 | February 2009 | March 2009 | April 2009 | May 2009 | June 2009 | July 2009
August 2009 | September 2009 | October 2009 | November 2009 | December 2009

2007 Safety Articles | 2008 Safety Articles

February 2009

Don’t get burned with space heaters

Space heating the smart way

You’re working in a drafty room and instinctively reach for the electric space heater switch to warm up your toes. Does it make economic sense to warm up with the quick fix of a space heater?

Think small and short. A general rule of thumb is that space heaters are ideal for occasional use in a small space. The Missouri Department of Natural Resources notes that if you turn your central heating system down a few degrees and supplement the heat in a small area with a space heater, you will probably save energy. If you don’t turn the thermostat down and simply add more heat with the electric space heater, you will likely increase your total bill.

You can turn down the thermostat and still be comfortable by managing your “thermal comfort.” Wear turtleneck sweaters and warm socks to feel warmer. At night, turn down the thermostat and stay warm with an electric blanket. You may be able to lower the thermostat by as much as 8 degrees and not feel any colder, while saving up to 15 percent on your heating bill, according to Gary Foremen writing in “Space Heater Efficiency”: www.thefrugallife.com.

Look for other heating fixes for large spaces used continuously. Using a space heater continuously in a large space will likely use more electricity than other fixes.

What are those other possible heating fixes? One is to have a heating, ventilation and air conditioning technician improve the ducting to the room; ducts may have come loose from the main trunk and are feeding warm air into the attic or crawl space instead of that cool room.

Another fix is to add insulation and to caulk and weatherstrip. An inexpensive fix is to strategically place fans at low speed to pull warm air from the rest of the house into the cooler space. These improvements will typically use less electricity than an electric space heater.

Space heaters are energy hogs. Though electric space heaters are 100 percent efficient in converting electric current to heat, they also are energy hogs. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, most space heaters use 3,000 to 11,000 watts! At that level of consumption, space heaters used to replace central heating could increase your overall energy costs by as much as 70 percent.

To figure out the cost of using a space heater, multiply the heater’s consumption in watts (look in its manual or on the back of the unit) by the number of hours the heater is on. Then divide by 1,000 to convert to kilowatt-hours, and multiply that by your average cost per kilowatt-hour – look for the latter on your electric bill or ask your electric cooperative for the rate.

So do electric space heaters make economic sense? Yes, for small spaces for short periods of time. Don’t use them as your primary source of heat.

The pros and cons of electric space heaters

The U.S. Department of Energy and Missouri Department of Natural Resources offer these pros and cons of electric space heaters:

Pros

  • No venting required for electric heaters; in contrast, combustion heaters that use gas or oil, for example, need venting to protect against carbon monoxide buildup
  • Clean, no fumes
  • Useful for heating a small space occasionally
  • Provide extra heat without the need to heat the whole house
  • Provide focused heat for heat-sensitive people, such as the sick or elderly

Cons

  • Can be more expensive to operate than combustion (use fossil fuels) space heaters
  • Potential burn and fire hazards – 25,000 space heater fires annually
  • Typically more expensive than forced-air systems or heat pumps to heat an entire house
  • Though 100 percent efficient in converting electric current to heat, they can use from 3,000 watts to more than 11,000 watts of electricity

Don’t become a space heater statistic: safety comes first

Space heaters cause more than 25,000 residential fires and 300 deaths annually in the United States, according to the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). Heaters can create a fire hazard when tipped over, placed too close to flammable objects or operated unsafely.

Read the CPSC’s free brochure about space heaters at www.cpsc.gov or call (800) 638-2772 for a copy. Also see the U.S. Department of Energy’s information at http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/consumer/your_home/space_heating_cooling/index.cfm/mytopic=12600. These sources, plus Underwriters Laboratories (an independent product-testing organization), offer the following safety tips for space heaters:

  • Never leave a portable heater running unattended or while asleep; don’t use it in a bedroom.
  • Select a heater of the proper size for the room you wish to heat; most heaters come with a sizing table.
  • Locate the heater on a level surface away from foot traffic, children and pets, and keep it at least three feet away from furniture, drapes, decorations and walls.
  • Do not use an extension cord unless absolutely necessary; if you must use a cord, make sure it’s 12-gauge — the lower the number, the heavier the wire; if the wire gets warm, you need a heavier cord.
  • Inspect the heater’s power cord regularly, and don’t use the heater if the cord is damaged.
  • Check periodically for a secure fit of the space heater’s plug in the wall outlet; if the plug becomes hot, the outlet may need to be replaced by a qualified technician.
  • Unless the heater is designed for use outdoors or in bathrooms, do not use it in damp, wet areas.
  • If your space heater is fueled by anything other than electricity — such as pellets, propane, natural gas or kerosene — use only the manufacturer’s approved fuel, and be sure the heater is properly vented to protect against carbon monoxide poisoning.
  • Only buy newer model heaters that have all the current safety features; make sure the heater has an Underwriters Laboratories label.
  • Only use portable heaters that have a tip-over safety shut-off device.

Shop for the right electric space heater

If you can justify the need — rather than merely the comfort of instant heat — for an electric space heater, there are lots of models and brands to choose from. To select the right heater for your needs, the Missouri Department of Natural Resources recommends:

  • Radiator-type heater for a room in constant use you want to maintain slightly warmer than the rest of the house. This type of heater doesn’t provide a quick warm-up, but it’s safer because the surface doesn’t get as hot as other types of heaters.
  • Convection models generally have a ribbon or wire heating element that uses natural air flow or a fan to warm up quickly. Bathrooms (keep away from water, however), workshops and seldom-used areas are good spaces for this type of heater. The surface does get hot enough to cause a fire or severe burn.
  • Radiant models warm people and objects — instead of the air in the room itself — just like the sun does. They often look like old-fashioned steam radiators and do a good job of quickly warming those closest to the heater, rather than providing heat for an entire room. As spot heaters, radiant models are ideal for a person at a workbench, in a chair or at a sewing machine. They can get hot enough to cause a fire or severe burn.

Since the government doesn’t test the performance of all portable electric space heaters, it’s difficult to compare manufacturing claims. But you can go to the following Web sites for testing information or consumer reviews. And, remember buyer beware: only buy recognizable brands from a trusted source.

  • www.amazon.com offers a wide selection of products, backed by buyer reviews.
  • www.consumerreports.org offers general buying information and lab test results, but you have to pay a fee to access the information.
  • www.consumersearch.com reviews the reviewers.
  • www.epinions.com is a space for consumers to review products; there are links for price comparisons.

When looking at models, the Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Energy Center at www.dnr.mo.gov/energy/residential/spaceheaters.htm suggests asking these questions:

  • Does the heater have a thermostat?
  • In what area of the house do you plan to use the heater?
  • Is the space heater safe for the area in your house in which you plan to use it?
  • What are the safety features of the space heater?
  • Some heaters have fans. Will the noise bother you?

Underwriters Laboratories, an independent product-testing organization, advises looking for these important safety features:

  • A tip-over safety switch, which automatically shuts off the heater if it’s knocked over
  • Thermostatic control, so the unit runs at full capacity to bring the room to the desired temperature and then switches to run at a lower level to maintain the temperature
  • Automatic shutoff if the appliance overheats — with a manual reset so you can check the unit and make sure it’s working properly before restarting it
  • Integrated carrying handle or wheels
  • Cool-to-the-touch cabinet
  • Multiple-year warranty
  • Timer that shuts off the unit after a set number of hours to prevent unintended operation
  • Easy-to-use digital readout for precise temperature control and other functions
  • Remote control that duplicates the functions on the control panel
  • Programmable timer to start the unit at a certain time

Frequently asked questions about CFL bulbs

What is a CFL?
CFL stands for compact fluorescent lamp. It is a small fluorescent light bulb that uses 75 percent less energy than a traditional incandescent bulb and can be screwed into a regular light socket.

Can using CFL lighting really save energy and save money on my electric bill?
Yes. A single 19 watt CFL bulb burns 56 watts less than a comparable 75 watt incandescent bulb and provides the same amount of pleasing, warm white light. Over the 10,000 hour life of a CFL bulb, you would save 560 kilowatt-hours. At 7 cents per kilowatt-hour, that’s a $39.20 energy cost savings per bulb. And don’t forget to deduct the cost of replacing 10 to 13 incandescent light bulbs, which generally last only 750 to 1,000 hours each.

Why do CFL bulbs cost more than incandescent bulbs?
The price of CFL bulbs reflects technology development costs. Also, each CFL bulb has a built-in bal-last which helps it come on. This adds to the cost. As the number of bulbs sold increases, the overall price will continue to decline. Plus, the initial cost is quickly made up in energy savings and reduced replacement costs since the bulbs last much longer.

Will a CFL bulb fit my light fixture?
CFL bulbs, which include a lamp and a ballast for transformer, come in many shapes and sizes. Great strides have been made in reducing the overall size, and many CFLs are now equivalent in size or smaller than incandescent bulbs. However, it is best to measure your fixture and compare bulb sizes before purchasing a CFL. The benefits of using these bulbs may make it more cost effective to re-place the fixture if it does not work with CFL bulbs.

Where should I use CFL bulbs?
Use CFL bulbs anyplace a traditional incandescent bulb is used. However, the most practical use for CFL bulbs is in a lamp or fixture turned on for at least three hours at a time. Hard-to-reach fixtures are also good candidates, since a CFL does not have to be changed as often as an incandescent bulb.

Can I use CFL bulbs in a fully enclosed fixture?
Yes, it is safe to use CFL bulbs that are 23 watts or below in a fully enclosed fixture.

Can CFL lights be dimmed?
There are dimmable CFL bulbs sold specifically for dimmable applications. Dimmable applications tend to have a small amount of electricity running through them even though a lamp is shut off. The lamp continually tries to turn itself on, which shortens the CFL life.

Can CFL bulbs be used where it is wet or damp?
CFL light bulbs can be installed in wet or damp locations as long as they are a covered bulb such as a flood lamp. Regular spiral CFLs may be installed in sheltered exterior locations.

Can CFL bulbs create interference with electronic equipment?
This product may cause interference with radios, cordless phones, televisions and remote controls. If interference occurs, move this product away from the device and plug into a different outlet.

What about air temperature and CFL bulbs?
CFL light bulbs may generally be used where the air temperature is between 20 degrees and 140 degrees. Above 140 degrees, there may be reduced light output and premature ballast failure. CFLs have a harder time starting below 32 degrees, reducing the brightness.

Can a CFL bulb be used in a dusk-to-dawn light fixture?
Dusk-to-dawn photocell fixtures designed for screw-in incandescent bulbs contain a silicon chip that converts radiant energy into electrical current. The technology is generally incompatible with screw-in CFL bulbs, shortening the life of the bulb. However, fixtures with built-in photocells that are designed to use only CFL lamps contain a delayed instant-on circuit to make them compatible with CFL bulbs.

What about electronic timers?
Electronic timers tend to have a small amount of electricity running through them even though a lamp is shut off. The lamp continually tries to turn itself on, which shortens the CFL life.

Do CFL bulbs give off ultraviolet light?
Compact fluorescent bulbs give off a minimal amount of UV light. It does not pose a hazard.

How long does it take for a CFL to reach full brightness?
The start-up time for CFL lamps varies. Most electronically ballasted units start their lamps instantly. All fluorescent lamps start at a lower light output. Depending on the ambient temperature, it may take anywhere from several seconds to several minutes for the lamp to come up to full brightness.

Should I be concerned about using CFLs in my home?
CFLs are safe to use in your home. No mercury is released when the bulbs are in use and they pose no more danger to you or your family than traditional incandescent bulbs when used properly.

How do I safely dispose of a CFL?
It is best to recycle your CFL. Recycling programs exist for mercury in older non-digital thermostats and mercury thermometers, but residential CFL recycling programs are just now appearing. If recycling is not an option in your area, place the CFL in a sealed plastic bag and dispose the same way you would batteries, oil-based paint and motor oil at your local Household Hazardous Waste Collection site. If that is not an option for you, seal the CFL in a plastic bag and place with your regular trash.

What should I do if I break a CFL?
If a CFL breaks, carefully sweep up all the fragments. Wipe the area with a wet towel and dispose of all fragments, including the used towel, in a sealed plastic bag. Follow disposal instructions above. If possible, open windows to allow the room to ventilate. Do not use a vacuum.

Doug Rye says . . .

Geothermal comes of age

We are postponing our discussion of the 10 Commandments of Energy Efficiency for a very important announcement. In October, President Bush signed the $700 billion Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 (H.R. 1424). In addition to helping stabilize the nation’s financial markets, the law also extended and enhanced tax credits and financing related to renewable energy and energy efficiency. And I am pleased to announce that included in the tax credits are — can you believe it? — geothermal heat pumps! For years, I have been teaching you about the advantages of geothermal heat pumps. Many of you have installed such systems in your houses or businesses and have learned that geothermal provides the most economical heating and cooling available in the marketplace. (Not to mention a percentage of domestic hot water for practically free.)

As I have said for years, 75 percent of the energy used in a geothermal heat pump is from solar British thermal units (Btus) that have been stored in the earth or, in other words, geothermal is 75 percent renewable energy. And it appears that the federal government now recognizes that. To me, just the recognition is huge. You see, no doubt about it, renewable energy can be feasible and is certainly needed. But it must be economically feasible for the average customer like you and me.

Lets look at some popular renewable energy sources:

No. 1: A typical solar voltaic system for a 2,000-square-foot house costs about $25,000. it would produce about 2 kilowatts for six hours per day (25 percent of the day) if the sun were shining. That means the system would produce enough electricity to power two 1,000-watt hair dryers. The estimated payback is around 50 years and the life expectancy of the system is 20 years. I personally don’t think that you can find a much worse investment. There is a tax credit available for this system in the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act.

No. 2: A typical wind generator for a 2,000-square-foot house costs between $10,000 and $20,000, depending on the size of the unit. It would typically produce 4 to 6 kilowatts of electricity if the wind was sufficiently blowing. In many parts of the United States, including Arkansas, residential wind generation is not a viable option. In fact, one of the most efficient wind farms in the U.S. only generated 30 percent of the time last year, with almost no generation during the hottest summer months. It is at best difficult to estimate the payback of a residential wind turbine because of such unknown factors as maintenance costs and the availability of wind flow. There is, however, a federal tax credit available in the new law.

No. 3: A typical geothermal heat pump for a 2,000-square-foot house should cost about $11,000 more than a conventional heating and cooling system. It does provide all of the heating and cooling required and it is available every single hour of every single day. The average payback for such a system will be seven to 10 years. The life expectancy of the geothermal unit is estimated to be 25 years, the loop in the ground is guaranteed for 50 years and no one actually knows how long it will last after that. And, yes, there is a federal tax credit available, at last!

Now, open your mind, think about it and you will probably be just as excited about this as I am. Geothermal has finally come of age! To learn more about the tax credits, visit www.energy.gov/taxbreaks.htm.

Doug Rye can be heard on KGOZ and KAAN locally. Every Saturday morning, Doug Rye hosts a live call-in show on several area radio stations. He can be heard from 9-10 a.m. on KGOZ, 101.7, Gallatin, and on KAAN, 95.5, Bethany.


Return to Top

PRINT THIS WINDOW
CLOSE THIS WINDOW